Lesson 2 2.7 Enrichment Methods

Problem: Calculate the mass of natural uranium feed and the Separative Work Units (SWU) needed to produce 1 kg of 3.5% enriched uranium with a tails assay of 0.3%.

Given:

  • P = 1 kg (product mass)
  • xₚ = 0.035 (3.5% enriched product)
  • x(f) = 0.00711 (natural uranium feed, 0.711%)
  • xₜ = 0.003 (0.3% tails)

Step 1: Calculate the feed mass (F) and tails mass (T)

Using the mass balance equations:

F=P+T...(i)F = P + T \quad \text{...(i)} Fxf=Pxp+Txt...(ii)F \cdot x_f = P \cdot x_p + T \cdot x_t \quad \text{...(ii)}

From (i): T = F - P = F - 1

Substituting into (ii):

F×0.00711=1×0.035+(F1)×0.003F \times 0.00711 = 1 \times 0.035 + (F - 1) \times 0.003

0.00711F=0.035+0.003F0.0030.00711F = 0.035 + 0.003F - 0.003

0.00711F0.003F=0.0320.00711F - 0.003F = 0.032

0.00411F=0.0320.00411F = 0.032

F=0.0320.00411=7.785 kg\boxed{F = \frac{0.032}{0.00411} = 7.785 \text{ kg}}

Therefore:

T=FP=7.7851=6.785 kgT = F - P = 7.785 - 1 = 6.785 \text{ kg}

Check: F x(f) = 7.785 x 0.00711 = 0.05531; P xₚ + T xₜ = 1 x 0.035 + 6.785 x 0.003 = 0.035 + 0.02036 = 0.05536. These agree (small rounding difference).

Result: To produce 1 kg of 3.5% enriched uranium with 0.3% tails, you need approximately 7.8 kg of natural uranium feed, generating approximately 6.8 kg of depleted uranium tails.

Step 2: Calculate the value functions V(x)

The value function is: V(x)=(2x1)ln(x1x)V(x) = (2x - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{x}{1-x}\right)

V(xₚ) — Product (xₚ = 0.035):

V(0.035)=(2×0.0351)ln(0.03510.035)V(0.035) = (2 \times 0.035 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.035}{1 - 0.035}\right)

=(0.071)ln(0.0350.965)= (0.07 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.035}{0.965}\right)

=(0.93)ln(0.03627)= (-0.93) \cdot \ln(0.03627)

=(0.93)(3.3168)= (-0.93) \cdot (-3.3168)

=3.085= 3.085

V(xₜ) — Tails (xₜ = 0.003):

V(0.003)=(2×0.0031)ln(0.00310.003)V(0.003) = (2 \times 0.003 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.003}{1 - 0.003}\right)

=(0.0061)ln(0.0030.997)= (0.006 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.003}{0.997}\right)

=(0.994)ln(0.003009)= (-0.994) \cdot \ln(0.003009)

=(0.994)(5.806)= (-0.994) \cdot (-5.806)

=5.771= 5.771

V(x(f)) — Feed (x(f) = 0.00711):

V(0.00711)=(2×0.007111)ln(0.0071110.00711)V(0.00711) = (2 \times 0.00711 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.00711}{1 - 0.00711}\right)

=(0.014221)ln(0.007110.99289)= (0.01422 - 1) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.00711}{0.99289}\right)

=(0.98578)ln(0.007161)= (-0.98578) \cdot \ln(0.007161)

=(0.98578)(4.9388)= (-0.98578) \cdot (-4.9388)

=4.868= 4.868

Step 3: Calculate the Separative Work (SW)

SW=PV(xp)+TV(xt)FV(xf)SW = P \cdot V(x_p) + T \cdot V(x_t) - F \cdot V(x_f)

SW=(1×3.085)+(6.785×5.771)(7.785×4.868)SW = (1 \times 3.085) + (6.785 \times 5.771) - (7.785 \times 4.868)

SW=3.085+39.15637.897SW = 3.085 + 39.156 - 37.897

SW4.34 kg-SWU\boxed{SW \approx 4.34 \text{ kg-SWU}}

Summary of Results:

  • Product mass (P): 1.000 kg
  • Product enrichment (xₚ): 3.5%
  • Feed mass (F): 7.785 kg natural U
  • Feed enrichment (x(f)): 0.711% (natural)
  • Tails mass (T): 6.785 kg
  • Tails assay (xₜ): 0.3%
  • Separative Work (SW): 4.34 kg-SWU

Interpretation: To produce 1 kg of 3.5% enriched uranium (with 0.3% tails), you need approximately 7.8 kg of natural uranium and 4.3 SWU of enrichment work. The cost of enrichment is then 4.3 multiplied by the price per SWU (typically $100-160/SWU in recent years).